🎓 Education & Student Updated November 20, 2026

University of Metaphysical Sciences Lawsuit: The Competitor Case and How It Ended

The University of Metaphysical Sciences lawsuit was a fight with a rival school, International Metaphysical Ministry. The last case was dismissed with prejudice on May 12, 2025, and there is no settlement for students to claim.

Category

Education & Student

Coverage

Case dismissed May 12, 2025; nothing to claim

Last Updated

November 20, 2026

Content Type

Legal Analysis

The Short Answer

The University of Metaphysical Sciences lawsuit is not a student class action. It is a long-running dispute between the school, which operates as Wisdom of the Heart Church, and a competing metaphysics school, International Metaphysical Ministry (IMM). The most recent case was dismissed with prejudice on May 12, 2025, by agreement of both sides, about a month before a scheduled jury trial.

As of November 20, 2026, there is no settlement fund, no claim form and nothing for students or graduates to file. No court or jury ever decided which school was right on the final claims, and the terms of the 2025 dismissal have not been made public.

Who Sued Whom

The University of Metaphysical Sciences (UMS) is a nonprofit distance learning school based in Arcata, California. A federal judge described both it and IMM, which is based in Sedona, Arizona, as nonprofits that teach a metaphysical approach to spiritual practice and ministry. IMM markets programs under names including “University of Metaphysics” and “University of Sedona.”

In every case we found, IMM was the plaintiff and UMS was the defendant. IMM’s 2021 complaint describes the two schools as direct competitors and says UMS is run by a former IMM student. We found no lawsuit by UMS students, and no case brought by a regulator or state attorney general.

The First Case: 2017 to 2019

IMM first sued on December 28, 2017, in federal court in Arizona, in International Metaphysical Ministry Inc. v. Schaefer, No. 3:17-cv-08280. According to the court, IMM sued UMS and its founder, Christine Breese, for copyright and trademark infringement and related state-law claims.

IMM alleged that UMS used look-alike websites and search keywords to steer students looking for IMM toward UMS, and that it launched attacks meant to knock IMM’s websites offline. UMS disputed this and told the court it would show it did not set up fake blog sites, run denial-of-service attacks or access IMM’s servers. These were allegations only and were never proven in court.

On July 24, 2018, the Arizona judge transferred the case to the Northern District of California. After a settlement conference, the court dismissed that case on June 12, 2019, and the schools signed a confidential settlement agreement on August 9, 2019. According to IMM’s later complaint, neither side admitted any of the allegations or liability. The agreement included a promise not to disparage each other and limits on using each other’s trademarks in advertising.

The 2021 Case Over the Settlement Agreement

IMM sued again on October 14, 2021, in International Metaphysical Ministry, Inc. v. Wisdom of the Heart Church, No. 4:21-cv-08066, in federal court in Oakland. This time the claim was breach of contract. IMM alleged that UMS broke the 2019 agreement with a February 2020 web page comparing itself to IMM and by running Google ads that used IMM’s school names.

UMS denied breaching the agreement and filed counterclaims. It argued that IMM skipped a required notice step before suing and that IMM itself used UMS’s name as an advertising keyword.

On September 9, 2022, Magistrate Judge Kandis A. Westmore narrowed the case sharply. She found that three of the names IMM relied on, “University of Metaphysics,” “University of Sedona” and “Theocentric Psychology,” were not registered trademarks or had void registrations, so the ad claim could not rest on them. IMM could pursue only alleged use of “International Metaphysical Ministry” before that mark’s registration was canceled on April 30, 2021. The judge denied IMM’s request for a ruling in its favor on the disparagement claim and let UMS’s counterclaims go forward.

The case then dragged on. In 2023 the judge canceled a trial date to decide whether the 2019 agreement should be rewritten, as IMM asked, or undone, as UMS asked. In an August 16, 2024 order rejecting a UMS jurisdiction challenge, the judge criticized the lawyers on both sides for personal attacks in their filings. A jury trial was later set for June 16, 2025.

How the Case Ended in 2025

The case never reached a jury. On May 12, 2025, the parties filed a stipulation to dismiss the action with prejudice, and the court closed the case that day. A dismissal with prejudice means IMM cannot bring the same claims again.

The court record does not show a judgment, a verdict or a finding that either school did anything wrong. We have not seen the dismissal papers themselves or any public statement of terms, so we cannot say whether money changed hands or whether the schools signed a new agreement. Court records are available on the docket at courtlistener.com.

For background on how disputes like this work, see our guide to trademark lawsuits.

ℹ️

Nothing to claim

This was a dispute between two schools. There is no class action, no settlement fund and no claim form for University of Metaphysical Sciences students or graduates.

Claims Online That We Could Not Verify

Many websites describe a University of Metaphysical Sciences class action by former students over accreditation or misleading degree claims, sometimes said to be in a California state court. We searched federal court records for every party name and found only the cases between IMM and UMS. We found no court record supporting a student class action, and we have left those claims out.

Accreditation was not the subject of the court rulings we reviewed. If you want to compare how real student consumer cases look, our page on the Walden University lawsuit covers a class action brought by students. Our verification standards explain why we rely on court records over aggregator posts.

What Happens Next

Because the 2021 case was dismissed with prejudice, there is no pending lawsuit between the two schools that we know of as of November 20, 2026. The court orders say the 2019 agreement covered disparagement and advertising; whether it still binds the schools depends on terms that are not public.

Some questions remain open. A trademark cancellation proceeding that the court mentioned, filed December 12, 2022, is outside the court case, and we have not confirmed its outcome. If a new case is filed by either school, or any agency or student files a case, we will add it here with the docket number.

People with a complaint about any school can contact their state attorney general or consumer protection office. That is a general option, not a sign that any agency is investigating UMS.

Before You Act

Thinking About Filing a Claim?

Many lawyers in injury and consumer cases work on contingency, taking a share of any recovery. Case costs can be owed separately, so read the written fee agreement before signing; see what lawyers charge. The Lawsuit Watch is not a law firm: we publish explainers, and we do not provide legal advice, representation or referrals. Your state bar directory is the reliable place to find and verify a lawyer.

Sources

Key figures and dates on this page were checked against the sources below on November 20, 2026. Settlement terms and status can change; confirm the current position with the court or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. How we verify.

University of Metaphysical Sciences Federal Court Case Dismissed

University of Metaphysical Sciences Lawsuit: The Competitor Case and How It Ended: Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the most common questions about this case and your legal options.

What is the University of Metaphysical Sciences lawsuit about?

It is a dispute between the school and a competing school, International Metaphysical Ministry, over trademarks, online advertising and alleged disparagement. It was not brought by students.

Was the University of Metaphysical Sciences lawsuit dismissed?

Yes. The most recent case, filed in 2021 in federal court in Oakland, was dismissed with prejudice on May 12, 2025, after both sides filed a stipulation. It ended before the scheduled June 2025 jury trial.

Is there a University of Metaphysical Sciences settlement I can claim?

No. There is no class action, settlement fund or claim form. Any terms between the two schools are private.

Did a court find that the University of Metaphysical Sciences did anything wrong?

No. The cases ended without a verdict or judgment finding wrongdoing by either school. A 2022 ruling narrowed the rival school’s claims but did not decide who was right.

Is there a student class action against the University of Metaphysical Sciences?

We found no court record of one as of November 20, 2026. Claims online about a student class action over accreditation do not match any case we could locate.

Who sued the University of Metaphysical Sciences?

International Metaphysical Ministry, a metaphysics school in Sedona, Arizona, sued in 2017 and again in 2021. The 2017 case settled in 2019, and the 2021 case was dismissed in 2025.

The Lawsuit Watch Legal Research Team

Education & Student Litigation Desk

The Lawsuit Watch publishes plain-language explainers on active consumer litigation: what a case alleges, who it may affect, and what the process involves. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice or representation. Where a figure or filing matters to a decision you are making, verify it against the court record or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. Last updated: November 20, 2026.