🎓 Education & Student Updated November 20, 2026

Financial Aid Antitrust Settlement: The $319 Million 568 Cartel Case, School by School

Twelve universities paid $319.25 million to settle claims that they colluded on financial aid. Claims are closed, the first $284 million was paid out in 2026, and five schools are still fighting the case.

Category

Education & Student

Coverage

Claims closed; first payments sent July 2026

Last Updated

November 20, 2026

Content Type

Legal Analysis

The Financial Aid Antitrust Settlement in Short

The financial aid antitrust settlement comes from Henry v. Brown University, No. 1:22-cv-00125 in federal court in Chicago, often called the “568 Cartel” case. Twelve of the 17 universities sued have agreed to pay a combined $319.25 million to former students who received need-based aid but still paid part of the cost of attendance. The settling schools deny wrongdoing.

As of November 20, 2026, the claim deadlines have passed: December 17, 2024 for the first ten settlements and December 27, 2025 for the Caltech and Johns Hopkins settlements. Payments from the first $284 million went out in July 2026. Money from the Caltech and Johns Hopkins settlements has not been distributed yet. Cornell, Georgetown, MIT, Notre Dame and Penn have not settled, and their part of the case is on appeal.

What the 568 Cartel Case Claims and Who Is Covered

Students sued in January 2022. The complaint says the schools, members of the former 568 Presidents Group, agreed on shared methods for calculating financial need and as a result gave less aid than they would have in open competition. The group was named for Section 568 of the Improving America’s Schools Act of 1994, which allowed need-blind schools to agree on aid principles. The complaint says the schools were not all need-blind and notes that the exemption expired on September 30, 2022.

The universities say the claims lack merit, that their aid policies were legal and pro-competitive, and that aid awards were not artificially reduced. No court has found that any school broke the law.

The settlement class covers U.S. citizens and permanent residents who attended a defendant’s full-time undergraduate program, received some need-based aid from that school, and did not have tuition, fees, room and board fully covered by grants or merit aid (loans do not count) in at least one year. For most schools the period runs from fall 2003 through February 28, 2024. It starts in fall 2004 for Brown, Dartmouth and Emory, fall 2019 for Caltech and fall 2021 for Johns Hopkins. Former students of the five non-settling schools are covered too.

Each School's Settlement Amount

Judge Matthew F. Kennelly approved the first ten settlements, totaling $284 million, in an order dated July 20, 2024:

  • Vanderbilt: $55 million
  • Northwestern: $43.5 million
  • Dartmouth: $33.75 million
  • Rice: $33.75 million
  • Columbia: $24 million
  • Duke: $24 million
  • Brown: $19.5 million
  • Emory: $18.5 million
  • Yale: $18.5 million
  • University of Chicago: $13.5 million

Two more followed. The court approved Caltech’s $16.75 million settlement on June 27, 2025 and Johns Hopkins’s $18.5 million settlement, which also required it to provide discovery, on July 30, 2025. Lawyers for the class were awarded one-third of the first $284 million, or about $94.7 million, and asked for one-third of the later $35.25 million. Because the case alleges a conspiracy, what a person receives does not depend on how much their own school paid.

Payment Status and Amounts

On July 2, 2026, the court approved the first distribution from the ten settlements. The administrator says electronic payments through ACH, PayPal, Zelle, Venmo or a virtual Mastercard started on July 20, 2026, and paper checks were mailed on July 28, 2026. By August 2026 it reported that all payments had been sent and more than 95 percent had been cashed.

People whose electronic payment failed got a Second Chance Payment Notice by email starting August 24, 2026, with a September 8 deadline to fix their details. Reattempts began September 18, 2026, and anyone who did not update was to be sent a paper check by October 2026. The court ordered that checks not cashed within 90 days become void.

Class counsel’s notices estimated, assuming about half of roughly 200,000 class members filed, an average of about $2,000 per claimant from the first ten settlements and about $250 from Caltech and Johns Hopkins combined. Actual amounts depend on the net price of the school attended, years of attendance and the number of valid claims.

⏰

Cash your check

The court ordered that settlement checks expire 90 days after they are issued. Virtual card notices come from financialaidantitrustsettlement@hawkmarketplace.com.

What Class Members Can Do Now

No new claims are being accepted. If you filed a valid claim and have not been paid from the first ten settlements, contact the administrator, Angeion Group, which says it answers questions in the order received. In January 2026 the court upheld the rejection of a group of claims that lacked required proof of class membership.

Keep your mailing address and email current with the administrator, since the Caltech and Johns Hopkins money and any future recovery from the remaining schools would be paid to the same claimants. Our guide on how long settlements take explains the gap between approval and payment.

The Case Against Cornell, Georgetown, MIT, Notre Dame and Penn

The five schools that did not settle are still defending the case. According to class counsel, the court denied their motion for summary judgment in full in January 2026. On June 1, 2026, Judge Kennelly certified a litigation class of students who attended the defendant schools with need-based aid, with class periods that vary by school, and the deadline to opt out of that class was August 22, 2026.

On August 24, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit agreed to hear the five schools’ appeal of class certification, limited to whether the trial judge adequately analyzed expert testimony. The court’s notice to the class said a jury trial was scheduled for November 2026, and the Cornell Daily Sun reported a November 4 start date. We could not confirm whether the trial has begun or was postponed because of the appeal.

Not the Same as the Early Decision Lawsuit

Several of these schools are also defendants in a newer case over early decision admissions, D’Amico v. Consortium on Financing Higher Education, filed in Massachusetts federal court in 2025. That case is about agreements on early decision applicants, not financial aid formulas, and it has no settlement. Our early decision lawsuit page covers it.

Money from the 568 Cartel settlements pays only members of this financial aid class. A claim filed here does not count in the early decision case, and the reverse is also true.

What Is Not Settled Yet

The Caltech and Johns Hopkins settlement money is still waiting on the administrator’s claim audit and a court order approving its distribution. No payment date has been announced as of November 20, 2026.

The claims against Cornell, Georgetown, MIT, Notre Dame and Penn are unresolved. The Seventh Circuit could uphold, narrow or overturn class certification, and any trial verdict or new settlement would lead to a separate payment process. Leftover settlement money that cannot be distributed efficiently is to go, with court approval, to charities that promote access to higher education. Our guide on whether settlements are taxable covers tax questions.

Before You Act

Thinking About Filing a Claim?

Many lawyers in injury and consumer cases work on contingency, taking a share of any recovery. Case costs can be owed separately, so read the written fee agreement before signing; see what lawyers charge. The Lawsuit Watch is not a law firm: we publish explainers, and we do not provide legal advice, representation or referrals. Your state bar directory is the reliable place to find and verify a lawyer.

Sources

Key figures and dates on this page were checked against the sources below on November 20, 2026. Settlement terms and status can change; confirm the current position with the court or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. How we verify. This settlement is also listed in our Settlement Tracker.

Antitrust Financial aid Universities

Financial Aid Antitrust Settlement: The $319 Million 568 Cartel Case, School by School: Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the most common questions about this case and your legal options.

What is the financial aid antitrust settlement?

It is $319.25 million from 12 universities in Henry v. Brown University, a federal class action in Chicago claiming elite schools colluded on financial aid formulas. The schools deny wrongdoing.

Which schools settled in the 568 Cartel case?

Brown, Caltech, Chicago, Columbia, Dartmouth, Duke, Emory, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Rice, Vanderbilt and Yale. Cornell, Georgetown, MIT, Notre Dame and Penn have not settled.

Can I still file a claim?

No. The claim deadline was December 17, 2024 for the first ten settlements and December 27, 2025 for the Caltech and Johns Hopkins settlements.

When were payments sent?

Electronic payments from the first $284 million started July 20, 2026 and checks were mailed July 28, 2026. Caltech and Johns Hopkins money has not been distributed as of November 20, 2026.

How much did each claimant get?

Class counsel estimated an average of about $2,000 from the first ten settlements if about half of an estimated 200,000 class members filed. Actual amounts depend on the school, years attended and number of claims.

Is the financial aid antitrust settlement legit?

Yes. A federal judge approved each settlement, and financialaidantitrustsettlement.com is the court-approved site run by the administrator Angeion Group.

The Lawsuit Watch Legal Research Team

Education & Student Litigation Desk

The Lawsuit Watch publishes plain-language explainers on active consumer litigation: what a case alleges, who it may affect, and what the process involves. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice or representation. Where a figure or filing matters to a decision you are making, verify it against the court record or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. Last updated: November 20, 2026.