🛒 Consumer Products Updated November 20, 2026

Gillece Lawsuit: $700,000 Restitution Settlement With the Pennsylvania Attorney General

Gillece Services settled the Pennsylvania Attorney General's consumer protection lawsuit in October 2026 for $700,000 in restitution. Eligible customers will be contacted by the AG's office and do not need to file a claim.

Category

Consumer Products

Coverage

Restitution pending; no claim needed, as of Nov. 20, 2026

Last Updated

November 20, 2026

Content Type

Legal Analysis

Gillece lawsuit: the short answer

The Gillece lawsuit is a consumer protection case the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General filed in 2020 against Gillece Services, the Pittsburgh-area plumbing, heating and cooling contractor, its owner and two employees. On October 22, 2026, Attorney General Dave Sunday announced a settlement in the form of a Consent Order filed in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas. It includes $700,000 in consumer restitution, $50,000 in costs and $250,000 in suspended civil penalties.

There is no claim form and no deadline. The AG’s office says eligible consumers “will be contacted by the Office of Attorney General and do not need to take any action.” As of November 20, 2026, the office has not published who qualifies, how much each person will get or when payments will go out. The settlement is not an admission that the law was violated.

What the Attorney General alleged

The lawsuit was announced on September 1, 2020 by then-Attorney General Josh Shapiro. It named Gillece Services, owner Thomas Gillece, former service manager James F. Hackwelder and field supervisor Joseph A. Nikoula. The office sought restitution for consumers, civil penalties and a ban from the plumbing industry.

The central allegation involved a “$93 or Free Clog Crusher Special” for sewer back-ups. According to the AG, technicians often told customers their clogs could not be cleared with a snake and needed costly excavation, and some customers later found other plumbers could clear the line. The office also alleged that customers were told their pipes had defects that did not exist, and that technicians used scare tactics such as gas leak and cracked heat exchanger diagnoses that third parties, including gas utilities, later discredited.

These were allegations made by the Attorney General. When the suit was filed, Gillece did not respond to a request for comment from KDKA, and we have not found a public statement from the company about the settlement.

What the court already decided in 2023

Part of the case was decided before the settlement. In August 2023, the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas ruled on summary judgment that Gillece and owner Tom Gillece Sr. violated the Pennsylvania Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act and/or the Consumer Protection Law. The court denied all of Gillece’s summary judgment motions, according to the AG’s office.

The findings covered these practices:

  • Refusing to honor customers’ requests to cancel home improvement contracts, and penalizing those who canceled
  • Failing to disclose, or misrepresenting, the right to cancel
  • Advertising that falsely or misleadingly described technicians as “certified,” “licensed” and “background-checked”
  • Failing to clearly disclose the terms of the “Clog Crusher” and “Same Day or You Don’t Pay” offers
  • Telling customers the law barred itemized invoices or required flat-rate pricing

The claims about unnecessary work and scare tactics were left for trial. The October 2026 settlement resolved them without a trial or a court finding on those points.

Gillece settlement terms

The 2026 Consent Order covers Gillece Services, LP, Gillece Plumbing and Heating, Inc., Thomas Gillece Sr., Thomas Gillece Jr., and the two former technicians. Beyond the money, Gillece agreed to new rules for how it diagnoses and sells work:

  • Technicians selling sewer excavation or hydro jetting must hold a NASSCO lateral assessment certification, and must document defects that meet NASSCO severity standards
  • If a line cannot be opened, technicians must make multiple attempts with a snake and tell customers they can get a second opinion
  • HVAC technicians must be NATE certified and use properly calibrated carbon monoxide meters
  • A gas leak diagnosis must generally be confirmed by the customer’s gas provider before Gillece sells a repair
  • A cracked heat exchanger diagnosis must be confirmed by two NATE-certified technicians
  • Customers must get copies of contracts and cancellation notices at signing

The 2023 court orders on cancellations, advertising and flat-rate pricing stay in effect. James F. Hackwelder and Joseph A. Nikoula are banned from the plumbing industry for five years. The $250,000 in civil penalties is suspended, meaning it is not being paid now. Gillece must also keep detailed records supporting its repair recommendations and give them to the AG’s office on request.

Who gets restitution and how

The AG’s office will decide who is eligible and contact those consumers directly. Its announcement, on attorneygeneral.gov, does not list eligibility rules, the time period covered or payment amounts.

  • Claim form: none
  • Claim deadline: none announced
  • Who decides eligibility: the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General
  • Payment date: not announced
  • Amount per person: not announced; the $700,000 is a total

Gillece customers who believe they were affected and have not been contacted can file a complaint with the AG’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, which listed 800-441-2555 and scams@attorneygeneral.gov in its 2020 announcement. Keep contracts, invoices, photos and any second-opinion estimates.

⚠️

No fee to get restitution

The AG's office says eligible consumers do not need to take any action. Be wary of anyone who asks for a fee or bank details to claim a Gillece refund.

Other Gillece lawsuits and similar cases

We found no verified private class action against Gillece. Some websites describe one, but we could not confirm it in court records or reliable reporting. This page covers only the Attorney General’s case.

Restitution in an AG case works differently from a class action settlement. There is no class notice, no opt-out process and no claims administrator. For a comparison with private group lawsuits, see how class action lawsuits work. For an individual dispute with a contractor, our guide to small claims court explains that route.

What is not settled yet

These points were open as of November 20, 2026:

  • The eligibility rules and the time period the restitution covers
  • How the $700,000 will be divided and when checks will be sent
  • Whether the suspended $250,000 penalty could ever be imposed, which depends on terms of the Consent Order that have not been published
  • Gillece’s compliance with the new technician and documentation rules, which the AG’s office can review on request

The AG’s office has not said when distribution will start, and we will update this page when it publishes details. For general timing, see how long settlements take, and for tax questions about refunds, see are lawsuit settlements taxable.

Before You Act

Thinking About Filing a Claim?

Many lawyers in injury and consumer cases work on contingency, taking a share of any recovery. Case costs can be owed separately, so read the written fee agreement before signing; see what lawyers charge. The Lawsuit Watch is not a law firm: we publish explainers, and we do not provide legal advice, representation or referrals. Your state bar directory is the reliable place to find and verify a lawyer.

Sources

Key figures and dates on this page were checked against the sources below on November 20, 2026. Settlement terms and status can change; confirm the current position with the court or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. How we verify. This settlement is also listed in our Settlement Tracker.

Home services Pennsylvania Attorney general

Gillece Lawsuit: $700,000 Restitution Settlement With the Pennsylvania Attorney General: Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to the most common questions about this case and your legal options.

What is the Gillece lawsuit about?

The Pennsylvania Attorney General sued Gillece Services in 2020, alleging it used a $93 Clog Crusher offer to sell unnecessary sewer excavation and used scare tactics. The case settled in October 2026.

How much is the Gillece settlement?

The Consent Order includes $700,000 in consumer restitution, $50,000 in costs and $250,000 in suspended civil penalties, according to the Pennsylvania Attorney General.

Do I need to file a claim for Gillece restitution?

No. The Attorney General’s office says eligible consumers will be contacted and do not need to take any action. There is no claim form.

Who qualifies for the Gillece restitution?

The Attorney General’s office decides eligibility and has not published the criteria as of November 20, 2026. Affected customers can file a complaint with the office’s Bureau of Consumer Protection.

Did Gillece admit wrongdoing?

The Attorney General states the settlement is not an admission of a violation of the law. Separately, a court ruled in 2023 that Gillece violated state consumer laws on cancellations, advertising and flat-rate pricing claims.

Is there a Gillece class action lawsuit?

We have not verified any private class action against Gillece. The confirmed case is the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s lawsuit in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.

The Lawsuit Watch Legal Research Team

Consumer Products Litigation Desk

The Lawsuit Watch publishes plain-language explainers on active consumer litigation: what a case alleges, who it may affect, and what the process involves. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice or representation. Where a figure or filing matters to a decision you are making, verify it against the court record or the official settlement administrator before relying on it. Last updated: November 20, 2026.